Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner

Stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner offers rich pigmentation and waterproof, smudge-proof wear for precise, long-lasting eye definition, ideal for oily or hooded lids.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Score

0.54

Total Upvotes

1371

Editorial Summary: Stila Stay All Day is kinda legendary for its staying power and pigmentation, especially if you have oily lids or want sharp wings. But heads up, lately some batches dry out fast or get flaky. Pricey but fans swear by it, just might be hit or miss now.

Pros

✓Long-lasting and stays put for hours
✓Highly pigmented with rich color payoff
✓Waterproof and smudge-proof formula
✓Easy to apply with precise micro tip
✓Works well on oily and hooded eyelids

Cons

✗Recent batches dry out quickly and have short lifespan
✗Formula inconsistency leading to patchiness and flaking
✗Some users experience irritation or eye discomfort
✗Difficult to remove without cleansing balm
✗Pricey compared to drugstore alternatives

Methodology: Analyzed 100+ Reddit user quotes from diverse beauty and makeup subreddits without date range; synthesized common themes on performance, formula, longevity, application, and comparisons for a balanced consumer perspective.

This analysis contributed to one of our key compilations:
Reddit Backed Starter Routine (PDF)

Related Products

Complementary

Alternatives

Asked by Redditors

Does Stila Stay All Day Eyeliner really stay all day?

Most users agree it lasts long and is waterproof, but some report smudging or fading after several hours, especially with recent formula changes.

Is the eyeliner suitable for sensitive eyes?

Many find it comfortable even with contacts, but a few users have experienced irritation or tearing when applied near the eye corners.

How long does one eyeliner last?

Lifespan varies; some report months of use if stored properly, while others experience drying out within weeks or a month.

Is it easy to apply for winged eyeliner?

Yes, the micro tip allows for precise lines and detailed winged looks, making it popular for creating sharp wings.

Are there better or cheaper alternatives?

Some users prefer drugstore brands like NYX or Asian brands like Clio and K-Palette for similar performance at lower prices.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

* [Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Intense Black (jet black)](https://www.ulta.com/stay-all-day-waterproof-liquid-eyeliner?productId=xlsImpprod1840049&sku=2215097&categoryId=cat80042)

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 435

* STILA Stay All Day Liquid (Midnight) - this was my first expensive eyeliner and will always have a place in my heart. But as I have to remain objective, I will slay down all unnecessary products! I loved navy at the time so of course felt drawn to the colour (which still is IMO super pretty). Pros: stays on for a decent while, good pigmentation, easy application, smudge proof, water proof Cons: felt tip, flakes off so you have to re-apply immediately or else it looks weird and also these flakes get into your eyes. WNRP

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 405

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 405

I got a new haul 2 days ago so I decided to do some cleaning/organizing and found a stila eyeliner I haven’t used. I have had before but it’s been years. This was a mini I must’ve gotten for free with points. Anyways I tested it on my hand, and it’s STILL there. After showering and washing my hands many times. I used it today and in the sweat humid land of Florida it did not budge. TLDR; Stila makes the best black eyeliner.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 116

stila Stay All Day Liquid Eyeliner in Intense Black: Basically your OG black liquid liner. The biggest difference I’ve found between higher end and drugstore liquid liners is that the pen runs out way faster the cheaper the product, so this is definitely worth it to me. I use this to define my lids before mascara.

u/HocusBunnySentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 96

The easiest way to get a Smokey eyeliner that looks delicious and my absolute fave is to get 5 different shades of brown. Start with a contour shade, then one that’s like a deer color, then a dark chocolate, then a light chocolate, then a black. Start with the lightest and work your way to the darkest using the shape you want. Clean the edges with a makeup wipe or face makeup. Then use a black liquid eyeliner. My favorite is stila “stay all day” liquid eyeliner. Use mascara on curled lashes then use falsies on the outer half of the eye. Looks sultry and sexy!!

u/No_College2419Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 63

I've been using Stila eyeliner for years and my last two are awful. It usually lasts 6 months before drying out and starts out gliding well and pigmented. I bought more recently and the first one dried up within a month and the new one is just as bad. They are going on dry and patchy and when I try to add more it starts pulling up and becoming even more patchy. I'm so upset cause I used to wear it everyday now I don't have the time or patience to mess with it everyday.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 63

Stila liquid liner forever🫶 legit used it for years and years and have never wanted to try anything else, I did try rare out of curiosity but I came back to stila

u/babyIemonadeSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 41

Don't know about their eyeliner, but their mascaras have gone to crap lately. Same issues as what you're describing with the eyeliner.

u/Spank_CakesSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 26

buy the stay all day dual-ended liquid eyeliner by stila at ulta😌😌😌 expensive ($32) but worth it. one side is thicker and the other is super thin and perfect for thin lines like this + amazing quality

u/mintysteam4269Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 19

Currently Showing 10 Reviews