Heroine Make Kiss Me Eyeliner

Kiss Me Heroine Make is a waterproof, smudge-proof liquid eyeliner with a super fine brush tip, ideal for long-lasting, precise application especially on oily and humid skin conditions.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Score

0.65

Total Upvotes

691

Editorial Summary: Kiss Me Heroine Make eyeliner is a solid choice if you want waterproof, smudgeproof liner with a super fine tip that works well on oily lids. Just watch out, it can dry out fast and some find it flakes or isn't super black. Overall a fan fave for lasting power and precision though.

Pros

✓Waterproof and smudge-proof formula resists sweat, oil, and humidity
✓Fine, precise brush tip allows for detailed application
✓Lasts long on oily and combination skin types
✓Affordable price point compared to some Western brands
✓Easy to remove with appropriate makeup remover

Cons

✗Ink may dry out quickly, often within 2-3 months
✗Some users find pigment less intense or patchy on eyelids
✗May flake or smudge for certain skin types or humid conditions
✗Not always as black or opaque as desired
✗Some users experience brush tip fraying or drying issues

Methodology: Analyzed 58 Reddit quotes from various beauty-related subreddits spanning multiple years, focusing on user experiences with Kiss Me Heroine Make eyeliner's formula, longevity, pigment, and application. Synthesized top pros and cons from community feedback.

This analysis contributed to one of our key compilations:
Reddit Backed Starter Routine (PDF)

Related Products

Complementary

Alternatives

Asked by Redditors

Is Kiss Me Heroine Make eyeliner waterproof?

Yes, it is known for its waterproof and smudge-proof formula that holds up well against sweat and humidity.

How long does the eyeliner last once opened?

Many users report it lasts about 2-3 months before drying out.

Is the brush tip fine and precise?

Yes, the brush tip is very fine (around 0.1mm) and ideal for detailed application.

Does it work well on oily eyelids?

Generally yes, it performs well on oily and combination skin, but results may vary individually.

Is it easy to remove?

It requires a good makeup remover, preferably an oil-based one, but it is removable without excessive tugging.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

Kiss Me Heroine Make Mascara & Eyeliner * smudge-proof, waterproof formulas that survive heat and humidity.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 380

Judydoll thin eyeliners. Probably the best I’ve had so far — very precise and pigmented. I absolutely hate my heroine eyeliner, idk if the ones I bought are just bad, but it barely shows up at all :/ just looks very sheer on my eye.

u/R253Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 89

Skin type: Oily Review: I applied Heroine Make Brown Eyeliner in the morning before going to work. No touch ups except for the time I used Gatsby Oil Blotting Paper in the afternoon on my face including my eyelids. I used to be a faithful user of Dolly Wink Eyeliner but this one is a bit cheaper and didn't smudge even after hitting the gym! Granted I don't sweat too much on the face but this definitely will be a repurchase for me.

u/blackcattttttSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 48

i have this eyeliner in black and somehow it doesn't draw properly on my eyelid (even when i use the EtudeHouse eye primer) :/ and it doesn't look black either. On the back of my hand it draws evenly and nicely tho. (e.g the last part of your eyeline looks kinda patchy/cracked and this is what annoys me ... when I use this eyeliner the whole line looks like this, not just the last wink :c ) I don't have this problem with the dolly wink eyeliner (not waterproof version).

u/japchaefanSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 45

Kiss Me Heroine - this one fares better, but I notice some of the eyeliner flakes off by around afternoon.

u/OPSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 44

Kiss me heroine make smooth liquid eyeliner- brown black and heroine make kiss me prime liquid eyeliner-black 3.5/5 - thin tip and doesn’t smudge. Good for a more natural or clean girl aesthetic - the og smooth version is not super opaque and runs out of ink quickly, like 2 months :( Thought I got a dud but the last 2 I have bought all have the same problem - the new prime version seems inkier but the ink seems to dry shiny -not in a glittery way- it just settles weirdly on my eyelids

u/OPSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 35

Kiss me heroine, and this dual eyeliner browit by nongchat. The tip is thinner and last longer than kiss me. I love their inner eyeliner too. Nongchat is great for humid, hot weather in SEA and oily lids.

u/cassiopeia18Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 34

I also like their brush eyeliners, its fine tipped, doesn't bleed across my hooded oily lids and lasts through sweat and grease from work (for reference I work at a barbeque place and my face is usually right up a charcoal grill). I've only tried the dark brown sonI couldn't tell you how black the black liner is, if you're into pitch black liners.

u/OVERWATCHLEAGUELORESentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 17

Heroine Make eyeliner. Their tip is 0.1mm

u/Flaky-Importance8863Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 16

Used to love the kiss me liquid liners but they kept drying out within 3 months, especially the brown shades and sometimes flakes 😩 Changed to the lilybyred AM9toPM9 survival pen liner and it definitely lasts longer. However the tip is thicker and less precise. The brown is also a darker shade that’s definitely more intense. Both don’t smudge but I find that the lilybyred lasts longer and never flakes on me.

u/mangoesandburritosSentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 16

Currently Showing 10 Reviews