MAC Liquidlast Waterproof Eyeliner

MAC Liquidlast is a waterproof, ultra-long-lasting black liquid eyeliner that stays put on oily, watery eyelids, delivering intense pigment and smudge-proof wear for days.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Score

0.70

Total Upvotes

167

Editorial Summary: This liner is seriously tough stuff—won't budge no matter what. Super black, great for oily lids, but boy, if you mess up your wing, you're stuck. The formula is thick and goopy, applicator kinda meh, plus it's kinda pricey. But if you want all-day no-fuss wear, it's a champ.

Pros

✓Exceptional long-lasting wear, even in extreme conditions
✓Highly waterproof and smudge-proof
✓Ideal for oily eyelids and watery eyes
✓Blackest, intense pigmentation
✓Stays put without fading or smudging

Cons

✗Difficult to apply; mistakes are hard to fix
✗Thick, goopy formula that can dry slowly
✗Applicator brush quality is poor
✗Pricey compared to alternatives
✗Formula may degrade before fully used

Methodology: Analysis based on 21 Reddit quotes collected from makeup-related subreddits, focusing on user experiences and opinions about MAC Liquidlast eyeliner, with discussions spanning various years and covering durability, application, and formula qualities.

This analysis contributed to one of our key compilations:
Reddit Backed Starter Routine (PDF)

Asked by Redditors

Is MAC Liquidlast eyeliner waterproof?

Yes, it is highly waterproof and suitable for swimming and sweating.

Can you easily fix mistakes during application?

No, mistakes can be hard to correct as the liner lasts for days.

Is the applicator brush good quality?

Many users find the built-in brush poor and prefer using their own brush.

Does it work well on oily or watery eyes?

Yes, it performs exceptionally well on oily eyelids and watery eyes.

Is it an affordable product?

It is considered pricey by some users compared to other eyeliners.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

Mac Liquidlast. This will not go anywhere. You can get dumped by your boyfriend while getting thrown off the side of a boat. Swim 20 miles to shore, walk 5 miles in the rainforest and it will look like you JUST applied it. I have been wearing black eyeliner for 20 years and have never been so afraid to use one. This one makes me hold my breath and pray to the make up gods that my wing is pointed to perfection. That’s the only downfall- if you mess up. Congratulations this is what you will look like for the next 3-5 business days. Pros: it’s last forever Cons: it last forever

u/Glad-Alternative894Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 54

Thinking to try: KVD, Diorshow, MAC liquidlast as last resort (I've heard good things about its lasting power, but apparently it's also a btch to apply haha)

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 42

-MAC Point black liquidlast liner

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 16

MAC liquidlast - amazing but hate the tip/applicator

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 10

MAC 24 hour liquidlast eyeliner... Is the absolute best

u/Tough-Boysenberry-38Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 6

MACs formula was too thick and took long to dry but had the best staying power...I even went snorkeling and it stayed on for the most part.

u/OPSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 6

I’ve tried a bunch, Kate, heroine make, dejavu, one day tattoo. None of them work for the truly oily lid + hooded and watery eyes. Only MAC liquidlast. Remember to use you own brush with that and not the one on the product because the formula is goopy, think of it as a thinner gel liner instead of a regular liquid liner.

u/scones_oolongSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 6

I do. I use Mac to fix it and it has less fallout. The brand and quality of the product makes a huge difference. Something I had to relearn recently when I forgot my eye makeup on an out of town trip. I ran into a store and purchased cheap makeup. It was such a disaster. I looked terrible

u/Bubbly_Walk_948Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 5

My favorite liner as of late has been MAC's Liquidlast, but that one's tough as nails; like, I know it'll stay no matter what I do.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 5

I used to use the Mac Liquidlast but it is too pricey for me right now and I am looking for something a little more affordable.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 3

Currently Showing 10 Reviews