Mineral Sunscreen

Reddit Rankings (by upvotes)

105 discussions analyzed

Reddit Analysis

Editorial Summary: Mineral sunscreens have improved: lightweight gels, sheer tints and hybrid fluids are popular. Favorites mentioned include Hero Force Shield (green tint, gel), La Roche‑Posay Anthelios (tinted fluid), EltaMD (tinted physical), Biore UV Kids Pure Milk (Japanese favorite), Good Molecules and InnBeauty (sheer/tinted options). Tradeoffs: white cast, pilling, finish and price — pick by tolerance and wear needs.

Recommendations:

Rosacea or redness: Hero Force Shield (green tint) or EltaMD tinted — calming textures and minimal irritation reported.
Acne‑prone or breakout‑prone skin: Good Molecules Sheer Mineral or Hero Force Shield — lightweight, gel/serum textures that many users say don’t clog.
Dry skin or need for glow: Peter Thomas Roth Max Mineral Tinted or Naked Sundays Collagen Glow — more hydrating, dewy finishes.
Oily or mattifying preference: Supergoop Mineral Matte Screen or some La Roche‑Posay Anthelios variants — drier, powdery finishes.
Darker or olive skin tones: Tinted mineral options (InnBeauty Mineral Sun Glow, La Roche‑Posay tinted, Naked Sundays) to minimize white cast.
Budget shoppers: Good Molecules or drugstore Korean/Japanese mineral options (Biore UV Kids popular) for affordable, wearable formulas.
Beach, sweat or water days: Biore UV Kids Pure Milk and certain water‑resistant mineral formulas often recommended for outdoor use.
Sensitive/eczema: Cotz, Blue Lizard and simple mineral lotions noted as gentler by users.
Makeup‑wearers/primer lovers: Supergoop Unseen (mineral or original) and silicone‑primer style minerals act as a primer under foundation.

Hero Cosmetics Force Shield Superlight Sunscreen SPF 30

🟢 32 positive reviews
🟡 14 neutral reviews
🔴 4 negative reviews

EltaMD Mineral Sunscreen SPF 46

🟢 20 positive reviews
🟡 2 neutral reviews
🔴 2 negative reviews

Innbeauty Mineral Sun Glow SPF 43 PA +++

🟢 14 positive reviews
🟡 3 neutral reviews
🔴 1 negative review

Naked Sundays Collagen Glow Mineral sunscreen

🟢 14 positive reviews
🟡 3 neutral reviews
🔴 1 negative review

Good Molecules Sheer Mineral Sunscreen SPF 30

🟢 10 positive reviews
🟡 1 neutral review
🔴 1 negative review

Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen SPF 40

🟢 80 positive reviews
🟡 31 neutral reviews
🔴 23 negative reviews

Biore UV Pure Milk Sunscreen SPF50+

🟢 24 positive reviews
🟡 4 neutral reviews
🔴 10 negative reviews

Peter Thomas Roth Max Mineral Tinted Sunscreen SPF 45

🟢 7 positive reviews
🟡 2 neutral reviews
🔴 1 negative review

La Roche-Posay Anthelios Mineral Sunscreen SPF 50

🟢 22 positive reviews
🟡 16 neutral reviews
🔴 15 negative reviews

Asked by Redditors

What is a mineral sunscreen and how does it work?

Mineral sunscreens use zinc oxide and/or titanium dioxide as physical filters that sit on the skin and reflect/ scatter UV. They often suit sensitive or reactive skin but can feel heavier or show a white cast on darker tones.

Will mineral sunscreen leave a white cast?

Some formulas do; newer tinted, sheer or gel mineral options reduce cast. People with deeper skin tones often prefer tinted shades or sheer formulations to avoid visible whitening.

Why does my mineral sunscreen pill or flake under makeup?

Pilling usually comes from incompatible layering (silicones, heavy creams or recent actives) or not letting products absorb. Apply sunscreen on dry, settled skin and wait a few minutes before makeup; avoid over‑layering.

Are all 'mineral' sunscreens 100% physical?

Not always. Some international ‘mineral’ formulas include boosters or chemical boosters (eg. certain esters) in non‑active roles. Read the active ingredient list for zinc oxide/titanium dioxide to confirm.

Application Tips by Redditors:

Apply sunscreen last in your AM routine after serums and moisturizer; spread an even, generous layer and wait a few minutes for any white cast to mellow before applying makeup.
To avoid pilling, let active treatments (retinoids, azelaic) fully absorb or use lightweight moisturizer between actives and sunscreen; reapply every two hours or after swimming/sweating.
If tint/finish is off, blend a drop of moisturizer or a small amount of foundation into the sunscreen to adjust shade and improve wear without sacrificing protection.