Mascara

Reddit Rankings (by upvotes)

96 discussions analyzed

Reddit Analysis

Editorial Summary: Mascara picks split into (1) long-hold "superproof" waterproof formulas (Heroine Make, Clio Kill Lash), (2) lengthening/separating silicones (Maybelline Sky High, L’Oréal Telescopic), (3) tubing/easy‑remove options (Thrive, Glossier Lash Slick), and (4) budget favourites (Essence Lash Princess). Do be aware of the tradeoffs in mascaras - curl and smudge resistance often mean tougher removal; brush shape heavily influences separation vs volume.

Recommendations:

Straight stubborn lashes or need all‑day curl — Clio Kill Lash Superproof or Heroine Make Long & Curl (use a primer/fixer and strong remover).
Oily lids or smudge concern — tubing mascaras (Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions) or Clio Kill Lash in its superproof version.
Want length and separation — Maybelline Sky High or L’Oréal Telescopic for dramatic length with a silicone/skinny wand.
Prefer easy removal / sensitive eyes — tubing mascaras like Thrive or Glossier Lash Slick (gentler on lashes during removal).
Budget shopping / good drugstore results — Essence Lash Princess (volumizing look for low cost).
Desire thick, dramatic volume — Heroine Make volumizing formulas or higher‑volume options (expect stronger removers).
Need a natural, fluttery finish — Glossier Lash Slick or brown shades of Sky High for softer definition.

Loreal Telescopic Waterproof Mascara

🟢 94 positive reviews
🟡 31 neutral reviews
🔴 30 negative reviews

Essence Lash Princess (Multiple Variants)

🟢 118 positive reviews
🟡 31 neutral reviews
🔴 48 negative reviews

Maybelline Sky High Mascara

🟢 129 positive reviews
🟡 44 neutral reviews
🔴 37 negative reviews

glossier lash stick

🟢 87 positive reviews
🟡 16 neutral reviews
🔴 25 negative reviews

Clio Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (Multiple Variants)

🟢 131 positive reviews
🟡 23 neutral reviews
🔴 39 negative reviews

Thrive Mascara

🟢 226 positive reviews
🟡 38 neutral reviews
🔴 68 negative reviews

Heroine Make Mascara

🟢 217 positive reviews
🟡 40 neutral reviews
🔴 55 negative reviews

Asked by Redditors

Waterproof vs tubing — which to choose?

Waterproof resists water and sweat but can be harder to remove; tubing mascaras (Thrive, some Maybelline Sky High users report tubing-like behavior) form removable tubes and are easier to wash off.

Why is removal difficult for some mascaras?

Very waterproof or film/advanced-film formulas (Heroine Make, some Clio variants) need oil-based removers or brand removers; vigorous rubbing can damage lashes — use a dedicated remover and gentle soak-and-slide technique.

How do I avoid clumping or spidery lashes?

Wipe excess product from the wand, use a thin combing wand first (L'Oreal Telescopic style), apply light layers and comb through with a clean spoolie between coats.

What works best for oily lids and no panda eyes?

Long-wear 'superproof' or tubing options like Clio Kill Lash (reports vary) and tubing mascaras generally resist smudging; sealing lid oil with primer/powder reduces transfer.

Application Tips by Redditors:

Wipe excess product on the tube rim or a tissue before application to avoid clumps and spidery lashes.
Build in light layers: apply one thin coat, comb through with a spoolie, then add a second coat where needed for volume or length.
If a mascara is hard to remove, soak a cotton pad in an oil or dedicated dual‑phase remover, hold it on closed lids for 20–30 seconds, then gently slide the product off — avoid tugging.