3 Images of the Reddit Backed Routine PDF in a collage style next to each other

Get our Reddit Backed Routine (PDF)

7 Best Mascara
(Ranked by 96+ Reddit Discussions)

Data Snapshot

Discussions analyzed

Products ranked

Reddit Analysis

Editorial Summary: Mascara picks split into (1) long-hold waterproof formulas (Heroine Make, Clio Kill Lash), (2) lengthening/separating silicones (Maybelline Sky High, L’Oréal Telescopic), (3) tubing/easy‑remove options (Thrive, Glossier Lash Stick), and (4) budget favourites (Essence Lash Princess). Do be aware of the tradeoffs in mascaras - curl and smudge resistance often mean tougher removal; brush shape heavily influences separation vs volume.Summarized by Tom and Lee.

Recommendations:

Straight stubborn lashes or need all‑day curl — Clio Kill Lash Superproof or Heroine Make Long & Curl (use a primer/fixer and strong remover).
Oily lids or smudge concern — tubing mascaras (Thrive Liquid Lash Extensions) or Clio Kill Lash Superproof
Want length and separation — Maybelline Sky High or L’Oréal Telescopic for dramatic length with a silicone/skinny wand.
Prefer easy removal / sensitive eyes — tubing mascaras like Thrive or Glossier Lash Slick (gentler on lashes during removal).
Budget shopping / good drugstore results — Essence Lash Princess (volumizing look for low cost).
Desire thick, dramatic volume — Heroine Make volumizing formulas or higher‑volume options (expect stronger removers).
Need a natural, fluttery finish — Glossier Lash Stick or brown shades of Maybelline Sky High for softer definition.

Loreal Telescopic Waterproof Mascara

Score:7.9/10

Sentiment155 mentions

94 positive31 neutral30 negative

Essence Lash Princess (Multiple Variants)

Score:6.8/10

Sentiment197 mentions

118 positive31 neutral48 negative

Maybelline Sky High Mascara

Score:6.5/10

Sentiment210 mentions

129 positive44 neutral37 negative

Glossier Lash Stick

Score:6.5/10

Sentiment128 mentions

87 positive16 neutral25 negative

Clio Kill Lash Superproof Mascara (Multiple Variants)

Score:6.3/10

Sentiment193 mentions

131 positive23 neutral39 negative

Thrive Mascara

Score:5.9/10

Sentiment332 mentions

226 positive38 neutral68 negative

Heroine Make Mascara

Score:5.7/10

Sentiment312 mentions

217 positive40 neutral55 negative

Why Trust Thorough Beauty

Rankings are based on real Reddit discussions using a Wilson Lower Bound (WLB) confidence score to reduce noise from products with very few mentions.

AI helps summarize patterns, but the underlying sentiment and quotes come from human Reddit posts. See our editorial approach.

Asked by Redditors

Waterproof vs tubing — which to choose?

Waterproof resists water and sweat but can be harder to remove; tubing mascaras (Thrive, some Maybelline Sky High users report tubing-like behavior) form removable tubes and are easier to wash off.

Why is removal difficult for some mascaras?

Very waterproof or film/advanced-film formulas (Heroine Make, some Clio variants) need oil-based removers or brand removers; vigorous rubbing can damage lashes — use a dedicated remover and gentle soak-and-slide technique.

How do I avoid clumping or spidery lashes?

Wipe excess product from the wand, use a thin combing wand first (L'Oreal Telescopic style), apply light layers and comb through with a clean spoolie between coats.

What works best for oily lids and no panda eyes?

Long-wear 'superproof' or tubing options like Clio Kill Lash (reports vary) and tubing mascaras generally resist smudging; sealing lid oil with primer/powder reduces transfer.

Application Tips by Redditors:

Wipe excess product on the tube rim or a tissue before application to avoid clumps and spidery lashes.
Build in light layers: apply one thin coat, comb through with a spoolie, then add a second coat where needed for volume or length.
If a mascara is hard to remove, soak a cotton pad in an oil or dedicated dual‑phase remover, hold it on closed lids for 20–30 seconds, then gently slide the product off — avoid tugging.

Related Categories:

Brow Gels

No related posts available.

Source discussions (10 of 96)