Icon

Thorough Beauty

3 Images of the Reddit Backed Routine PDF in a collage style next to each other

Get our Reddit Backed Routine (PDF)

8 Best Lipsticks
(Ranked by 256+ Reddit Discussions)

Data Snapshot

Discussions analyzed
256
Products ranked
8
Reddit Analysis

Editorial Summary: Reddit groups lip products into 3 groups - (1) ultra long‑wear liquid stains (Maybelline SuperStay, NARS, Peripera) that lock color but can be drying; (2) sheer balm‑like finishes (Glossier Gen G, Clinique) for natural looks; and (3) creamy bullets (Revlon Super Lustrous) for comfortable wear. Key themes: drugstore long‑wears perform well, prep matters, and oil‑based removal is essential.Summarized by Tom and Lee.

Recommendations:
  • Need all‑day, transfer‑resistant color: Maybelline SuperStay Lipsticks, NARS Powermatte or CoverGirl Outlast — best when staying power is top priority but expect firmer feel and tougher removal.
  • Prefer a sheer, blotted, ‘no‑makeup’ finish: Glossier Generation G or Peripera Ink Airy/Velvet — lighter, buildable color that reads natural but won’t last as long as stains.
  • Have dry or sensitive lips: Clinique Almost Lipstick or Revlon Super Lustrous — creamier, more comfortable wear and easier to layer with balms.
  • Want a pigmented tint that stains: Peripera Ink Velvet or traditional lip‑stain/marker formulas (CoverGirl Outlast predecessors, some Maybelline 24‑hr variants) — good stain longevity with lighter feel but can be drying.
  • Need cruelty‑free or indie alternatives: look to cruelty‑free brands with long‑wear tint lines (for example ColourPop and selected indie tintmakers) and verify current ingredient/market status before purchase.
  • On a budget but want performance: drugstore long‑wears like Maybelline SuperStay and Revlon Super Lustrous deliver strong results for the price.
  • Want a glossy, high‑impact finish that still lasts: Maybelline SuperStay Vinyl Ink or glossy long‑wear hybrids — they give shine plus decent wear but may transfer more than matte stains.
  • Looking for multi‑use (cheeks + lips): choose cream bullets or sheer tints (Revlon Super Lustrous, Glossier Generation G) that blend well into skin and double as cream blushes.
#1
Revlon Super Lustrous

Revlon Super Lustrous

Score:8.3/10
Sentiment48 mentions
37 positive9 neutral2 negative
#2
Maybelline Super Stay Lipsticks

Maybelline Super Stay Lipsticks

Score:6.9/10
Sentiment161 mentions
105 positive23 neutral33 negative
#3
NARS - Powermatte Lip Pigment

NARS - Powermatte Lip Pigment

Score:6.7/10
Sentiment26 mentions
16 positive8 neutral2 negative
#4
COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color

COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color

Score:5.6/10
Sentiment70 mentions
30 positive28 neutral12 negative
#5
Clinique Almost Lipstick

Clinique Almost Lipstick

Score:5.4/10
Sentiment44 mentions
29 positive2 neutral13 negative
#6
Glossier Generation G Lipstick

Glossier Generation G Lipstick

Score:5.2/10
Sentiment107 mentions
54 positive21 neutral32 negative
#7
Peripera Ink the Velvet Lip Tint

Peripera Ink the Velvet Lip Tint

Score:4.8/10
Sentiment44 mentions
22 positive10 neutral12 negative
#8
Huda Beauty Liquid Matte Lipstick

Huda Beauty Liquid Matte Lipstick

Score:3.8/10
Sentiment46 mentions
19 positive11 neutral16 negative

Why Trust Thorough Beauty

Rankings are based on real Reddit discussions using a Wilson Lower Bound (WLB) confidence score to reduce noise from products with very few mentions.

AI helps summarize patterns, but the underlying sentiment and quotes come from human Reddit posts. See our editorial approach.

Asked by Redditors

Which lipstick types last the longest?
Liquid stains and long‑wear liquid mattes (examples: Maybelline SuperStay lines, NARS Powermatte, Peripera Ink Velvet, CoverGirl Outlast) tend to deliver the best all‑day wear; expect trade‑offs like more tackiness, potential dryness, and harder removal.
Are long‑wear lip products transfer‑proof?
Many formulas become effectively transfer‑resistant after full dry‑down, but glossy/vinyl finishes and newly applied product can still transfer. Expect variability by shade and formula — dark or glossy shades may show more evidence of transfer.
How do I remove very long‑wear lipstick?
Use an oil‑based remover or cleansing balm and gentle rubbing; ordinary water or micellar wipes often won’t fully remove stain formulas and some require repeated oil cleansing to lift all color.
What if I have dry or sensitive lips?
Seek creamier, balm‑hybrid or sheer formulas (Clinique Almost Lipstick, Revlon Super Lustrous, balm‑topped two‑step systems) and always patch test new formulas. Prepping (exfoliate + hydrate) helps, and avoid the driest liquid mattes unless you’ll layer with a conditioning topcoat.
Can I use lipstick as blush or multi‑use color?
Yes — many users apply cream bullets or sheer tints (Revlon Super Lustrous, Peripera, Glossier Gen G) to cheeks for a coordinated wash; apply sparingly and blend quickly to avoid patchiness.
Why do some lipsticks pill, go patchy, or smell odd?
Pilling/patchiness often comes from over‑application, incompatible skin oils, or uneven dry‑down; reformulations and fragranced releases (noted with some Peripera/Glossier items) can change texture and scent, so check recent reviews and swatches before buying.

Application Tips by Redditors:

  • Prep lips: gently exfoliate, apply a lightweight balm, wait 5–10 minutes and blot off excess before applying long‑wear formulas to reduce flaking and uneven wear.
  • Build thin layers and blot: apply thin coats, let each layer set or blot with tissue to avoid tacky, gummy buildup and to improve even staining.
  • Remove safely: use an oil‑based cleanser or dedicated long‑wear remover and massage gently; repeat if needed rather than aggressive scrubbing to avoid irritation.

Related Categories:

Related Posts:

No related posts available.
Source discussions (10 of 256)