Lipsticks

Reddit Rankings (by upvotes)

256 discussions analyzed

Reddit Analysis

Editorial Summary: Reddit groups lip products into 3 groups - (1) ultra long‑wear liquid stains (Maybelline SuperStay, NARS, Peripera) that lock color but can be drying; (2) sheer balm‑like finishes (Glossier Gen G, Clinique) for natural looks; and (3) creamy bullets (Revlon Super Lustrous) for comfortable wear. Key themes: drugstore long‑wears perform well, prep matters, and oil‑based removal is essential.

Recommendations:

Need all‑day, transfer‑resistant color: Maybelline SuperStay Matte Ink, Maybelline SuperStay Vinyl Ink, NARS Powermatte or CoverGirl Outlast — best when staying power is top priority but expect firmer feel and tougher removal.
Prefer a sheer, blotted, ‘no‑makeup’ finish: Glossier Generation G or Peripera Ink Airy/Velvet — lighter, buildable color that reads natural but won’t last as long as stains.
Have dry or sensitive lips: Clinique Almost Lipstick or Revlon Super Lustrous bullets — creamier, more comfortable wear and easier to layer with balms.
Want a pigmented tint that stains: Peripera Ink Velvet or traditional lip‑stain/marker formulas (CoverGirl Outlast predecessors, some Maybelline 24‑hr variants) — good stain longevity with lighter feel but can be drying.
Need cruelty‑free or indie alternatives: look to cruelty‑free brands with long‑wear tint lines (for example ColourPop and selected indie tintmakers) and verify current ingredient/market status before purchase.
On a budget but want performance: drugstore long‑wears like Maybelline SuperStay and Revlon Super Lustrous deliver strong results for the price.
Want a glossy, high‑impact finish that still lasts: Maybelline SuperStay Vinyl Ink or glossy long‑wear hybrids — they give shine plus decent wear but may transfer more than matte stains.
Looking for multi‑use (cheeks + lips): choose cream bullets or sheer tints (Revlon Super Lustrous, Glossier Gen G) that blend well into skin and double as cream blushes.

Revlon Super Lustrous

🟢 37 positive reviews
🟡 9 neutral reviews
🔴 2 negative reviews

Maybelline Super Stay Lipsticks

🟢 105 positive reviews
🟡 23 neutral reviews
🔴 33 negative reviews

NARS - Powermatte Lip Pigment

🟢 16 positive reviews
🟡 8 neutral reviews
🔴 2 negative reviews

COVERGIRL Outlast All-Day Lip Color

🟢 30 positive reviews
🟡 28 neutral reviews
🔴 12 negative reviews

Clinique Almost Lipstick

🟢 29 positive reviews
🟡 2 neutral reviews
🔴 13 negative reviews

Glossier Generation G Lipstick

🟢 54 positive reviews
🟡 21 neutral reviews
🔴 32 negative reviews

Peripera Ink the Velvet Lip Tint

🟢 22 positive reviews
🟡 10 neutral reviews
🔴 12 negative reviews

Huda Beauty Liquid Matte Lipstick

🟢 19 positive reviews
🟡 11 neutral reviews
🔴 16 negative reviews

Asked by Redditors

Which lipstick types last the longest?

Liquid stains and long‑wear liquid mattes (examples: Maybelline SuperStay lines, NARS Powermatte, Peripera Ink Velvet, CoverGirl Outlast) tend to deliver the best all‑day wear; expect trade‑offs like more tackiness, potential dryness, and harder removal.

Are long‑wear lip products transfer‑proof?

Many formulas become effectively transfer‑resistant after full dry‑down, but glossy/vinyl finishes and newly applied product can still transfer. Expect variability by shade and formula — dark or glossy shades may show more evidence of transfer.

How do I remove very long‑wear lipstick?

Use an oil‑based remover or cleansing balm and gentle rubbing; ordinary water or micellar wipes often won’t fully remove stain formulas and some require repeated oil cleansing to lift all color.

What if I have dry or sensitive lips?

Seek creamier, balm‑hybrid or sheer formulas (Clinique Almost Lipstick, Revlon Super Lustrous, balm‑topped two‑step systems) and always patch test new formulas. Prepping (exfoliate + hydrate) helps, and avoid the driest liquid mattes unless you’ll layer with a conditioning topcoat.

Can I use lipstick as blush or multi‑use color?

Yes — many users apply cream bullets or sheer tints (Revlon Super Lustrous, Peripera, Glossier Gen G) to cheeks for a coordinated wash; apply sparingly and blend quickly to avoid patchiness.

Why do some lipsticks pill, go patchy, or smell odd?

Pilling/patchiness often comes from over‑application, incompatible skin oils, or uneven dry‑down; reformulations and fragranced releases (noted with some Peripera/Glossier items) can change texture and scent, so check recent reviews and swatches before buying.

Application Tips by Redditors:

Prep lips: gently exfoliate, apply a lightweight balm, wait 5–10 minutes and blot off excess before applying long‑wear formulas to reduce flaking and uneven wear.
Build thin layers and blot: apply thin coats, let each layer set or blot with tissue to avoid tacky, gummy buildup and to improve even staining.
Remove safely: use an oil‑based cleanser or dedicated long‑wear remover and massage gently; repeat if needed rather than aggressive scrubbing to avoid irritation.