Clio Sharp So Simple Eyeliner

Clio Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner is a budget-friendly, long-lasting eyeliner perfect for oily eyelids and subtle, smudge-resistant looks.

See Product

We may earn a small commission if you click our link. It helps support the cost of running our analysis and keeping this site independent.

Rankings by Sentiment Analysis

Reddit Rank

Score

0.70

Total Upvotes

587

Editorial Summary: Clio Sharp So Simple eyeliner is a solid waterproof option that sticks well on oily lids and offers good pigmentation for a natural look. Not the creamiest or most precise, but affordable and reliable if you use primer. Great for everyday wear and tightlining.

Pros

✓Waterproof and long-lasting, ideal for oily eyelids
✓Good pigmentation with natural and subtle shades
✓Affordable compared to other brands
✓Suitable for no-makeup makeup and tightlining
✓Available in both pencil and felt tip forms

Cons

✗Not as smooth or creamy as some competitors
✗Can smudge or bleed without primer, especially on oily lids
✗Tip not as fine or precise as some users prefer
✗Some report it snagging during application
✗Formula changes may affect performance

Methodology: Analyzed 26 quotes from various Reddit beauty discussions focusing on AsianBeauty and KoreanBeauty subreddits. Quotes span user experiences with formula, wear time, pigmentation, and application, prioritizing common themes such as longevity, suitability for oily eyelids, and tip precision.

This analysis contributed to one of our key compilations:
Reddit Backed Starter Routine (PDF)

Related Products

Complementary

Alternatives

Asked by Redditors

Is Clio Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner good for oily eyelids?

Yes, many users with oily eyelids find it stays put all day when paired with a primer.

Can this eyeliner be used on the waterline?

Yes, it is waterproof and can be applied on the waterline for a subtle look.

How do I prevent smudging with this eyeliner?

Using an eye primer and setting powder can help control oil and prevent smudging.

Is the tip fine enough for precise lines?

Some users find the tip less fine than desired, but it can still create defined lines and wings.

How does it compare to other brands?

It’s more affordable but less creamy than brands like Canmake; gel versions have better staying power.

Reddit Reviews:

Calculated by the the number of posts or comments that have an opinion on this product

Positive

Neutral

Negative

CLIO Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner (Renewal) in Vanilla Beige and Black Brown (10/10): VB for aegyosal shadow and triangle zone, black brown for emphasizing lash line. Perfect no makeup makeup staple, doesn’t move all day and blends with precise, thick brush. WRP.

u/unknownSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 252

Clio sharp so simple eyeliner 😍

u/[original poster]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 167

i literally have finally found my hg combo for pencil eyeliner (i have the oilest eyelids known to man) .. primer + clio pencil eyeliner GOT ME SNATCHED ALL DAY!!!! THIS PIC WAS TAKEN AFTER LIKE 8 HOURS?? AND IT DOESNT ALL TRANSFER TO UNDER MY EYES AND DISAPPEAR 😭🙏 I also had it on after 30 sweaty minutes on the stairmaster and it didnt even budge that much 😭🙏🙏 Literally bless

u/OPSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 69

The Clio sharp so simple pencil liner is nice but its not as smooth and creamy as Canmake's.

u/Firm_Pair_4902Sentiment: likely neutral Upvotes: 62

Clio- seems to run down as well and bleed. Doesn’t come up as fine as I would like it to be.

u/[original poster]Sentiment: likely negative Upvotes: 44

Clio sharp so simple pencil eyeliner in dark brown for the more subtle and natural look, it also can be worked into wings.

u/hirentotsuSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 25

Not Sephora, but Clio black kill. You can get it on amazon

u/cheetoloverSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 23

I have the other sharp so simple gel liner from Clio, and think it has much better staying power.

u/[deleted]Sentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 15

Clio sharp eyeliner and the Wakemake pencil eyeliner are great, though honestly I would recommend Japanese eyeliners more like Flowfushi/Heroine Make/Dolly Wink liquid eyeliners which are a HG of many, or Canmake's pencil eyeliner.

u/theteacupdragonSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 5

Wasn’t sure which Clio you tried, but I like the Clio Sharp, So Simple (pencil) and the Superproof Pen Liner (liquid). There’s always going to be some wearing away, but I find that primer and a little bit of nude toned powder eyeshadow help with oil control more than just the primer itself. Also not sure which primer you’re using, but it might be worth changing that up too. Good luck!

u/crashmetothegroundSentiment: likely positive Upvotes: 5

Currently Showing 10 Reviews